Publications /
Opinion

Back
Overcoming Obstacles to Regional Integration in the Southern Mediterranean: The Case of Energy
Authors
April 10, 2023

The contemporary global energy landscape is experiencing noteworthy changes in demand, supply, technology, markets, and investment. These developments transcend conventional oil and gas security considerations. Renewable energy sources, such as wind and solar power, have become increasingly cost-effective compared to fossil fuels, and the minerals required to produce them are gaining importance. Nevertheless, recent events such as the Covid-19 pandemic and the conflict in Ukraine have temporarily refocused attention on oil and gas. Despite this, the ongoing transition towards a sustainable energy future implies that the world confronts a distinct type of crisis whereby nations need to balance immediate energy security and economic progress with long-term decarbonization.  Considering these transformations, an interconnected and integrated energy system is more crucial than ever, particularly in the southern Mediterranean region.

From an economic perspective, the case for South-South integration is clear. The existing boundaries between countries resulting from geographical distances, inadequate infrastructure, and ineffective policies hinder economic growth. Theoretically, regional integration allows countries to overcome these costly divisions by integrating goods, services, and markets, facilitating the flow of trade, capital, energy, people, and ideas. Shared physical and institutional infrastructure is vital for achieving regional integration. Specifically, it requires countries to cooperate on (i) trade, investment, and domestic regulation; (ii) transport, information and communications technology (ICT), and energy infrastructure; (iii) macroeconomic and financial policies; and (iv) the provision of other common public goods (e.g., shared natural resources, security, education).

The significance of accelerating regional integration cannot be overstated in the aftermath of various crises that have disrupted Mediterranean countries' economies in recent years. Amongst numerous avenues for pursuing this agenda, few are as crucial as energy at present. Intra-Mediterranean trade is currently valued at less than $1 trillion per annum, representing only a third of the trade between the Mediterranean and the rest of the world. In contrast, prosperous regions frequently display patterns where neighboring countries are their most prominent trading partners. Energy constitutes roughly a third of the regional trade within this narrow ambit. Additionally, trade links among southern Mediterranean countries are minimal, with most trading occurring between these countries and the European Union, especially in the energy sector. As such, the Euro-Mediterranean energy relationship has yet to transition from a bilateral approach to a more regional approach.

Achieving an interconnected energy market is not a simple process. Several factors hinder regional integration and need to be identified and addressed. Countries may prioritize regional integration differently while assessing its impact on trade and investment flows, economic activity allocation, and income distribution can be challenging. The North African electricity interconnections provide an illustrative example of these challenges. Due to energy policies oriented towards national interests, the North African power systems are fragmented into five separate electricity markets predominantly governed by monopolistic state utilities. Despite some efforts to promote regional cooperation and the desire to establish integrated power markets in the future, electricity exchanges between the five North African countries remain negligible due to insufficient physical electricity interconnections. To a slightly greater extent, electricity trade occurs more between North Africa and its neighbouring regions of Europe and the Middle East. For instance, in 1997 and 1998, the first electricity interconnectors were constructed between Morocco and Spain and between Egypt and Jordan respectively. In 2006 a second interconnection between Morocco and Spain was built, providing a combined nominal capacity of 1.4 GW, and in 2019, Spain and Morocco signed a Memorandum of Understanding to build a third electricity interconnection cable between both countries to be commissioned in 2026.

Furthermore, unsuitable complementary policies and institutions can lead to ineffective outcomes. In addition, regional integration may result in winners and losers, with some groups or regions benefiting more than others, even within the same country. Therefore, an effective and transparent institutional governance framework is equally vital in addition to physical infrastructure. This is necessary for regional integration to achieve significant scale and attract new private and public traders. It entails the formulation of market rules and regulations that encourage equitable competition, as well as the introduction of appropriate financing mechanisms. A level playing field also necessitates that some electricity trade be based on international fuel prices, promoting domestic policy reforms aimed at phasing out subsidized generation fuels and ending user tariffs.

Notwithstanding these challenges, leveraging the potential for greater economic integration among the southern Mediterranean countries could have a transformative impact on the energy landscape. Fossil fuels continue to dominate energy production and trade in the region, with Algeria, Libya, and Egypt being the primary producers, while Morocco and Egypt are experiencing an upswing in renewable energy usage. Furthermore, several external factors, such as Europe’s heightened demand for oil and gas in the short run, influence energy policies in the southern Mediterranean. However, this raises the issue of balancing Europe's energy requirements with domestic demand. In this sense, Algeria has demonstrated its willingness and capacity to increase gas supplies to Europe, while Egypt is making strides in establishing itself as a vital regional hub for natural gas processing and re-exportation, on the condition that domestic demand will systematically take precedence over exports.

Consider the example of natural gas and its potential role in fostering regional integration in the Eastern Mediterranean. The region's significant gas reserves are primarily located in deep water, which makes production costs prohibitively high. As a result, identifying markets where gas can be competitive is a primary challenge, and exploration and development efforts will not be feasible until the competitiveness of the known resources is established. To this end, regional cooperation could be instrumental in unlocking the value of gas in the region. Achieving competitive prices necessitates large-scale trading, as gas value chains typically require a sizable resource that can be efficiently linked to a significant market. Such an undertaking would justify the necessary investment in infrastructure for gas transport. One promising development in this regard is the East Mediterranean Gas Forum (EMGF), which offers a platform for regional cooperation among gas-producing and consuming countries in the Eastern Mediterranean.

In essence, the objective of the EMGF is to enhance collaboration among governments and minimize expenses and risks, draw in investors, and enhance market competitiveness for the area's gas industry. Such a gas hub for the Eastern Mediterranean region could develop on the northern coast of Egypt, based on the strengths of Egypt's domestic gas demand and the possibility of using its infrastructure to handle supplies from neighboring countries. Nonetheless, several aspects require attention to ensure the success of this regional collaboration initiative. These comprise the liberalization of the gas market to encourage competitive trade, the synchronization of pricing mechanisms, and the elimination of trade hindrances such as energy subsidies. Additionally, implementing an enabling fiscal framework to cut the cost of gas supply to regional and international markets and facilitate the use of shared infrastructure is also essential.

Regarding renewable energy, several initiatives are currently underway in the southern Mediterranean region, such as solar, wind, and hydrogen projects, specifically in Egypt and Morocco. In particular, North Africa has increased  its renewable energy production by 40% over the last decade adding 4.5 GW of wind, solar PV, and solar thermal capacity to its renewable energy power fleet. However, these endeavors appear to be primarily led by individual countries, and there is no discernible and effective regional South-South cooperation. There is also emerging competition in this region, especially regarding clean hydrogen development. The European Union's interest in this emerging market and its potential as an export market could exacerbate this competition.

Furthermore, several technical, financial, and economic barriers hinder the development of a cost-competitive hydrogen industry. The development of an efficient and sustainable hydrogen industry requires significant investment in research and development, as well as in infrastructure. Moreover, the cost of renewable energy technologies, such as solar and wind, must continue to decrease to make the production of green hydrogen cost competitive. Additionally, the lack of regulatory frameworks and the absence of adequate financing mechanisms pose significant obstacles to establishing a hydrogen industry in the region.

In conclusion, international experience demonstrates that developing regional institutional capacity, acquiring the necessary financing to improve infrastructure, and establishing a cooperative security framework are intricate processes that demand sustained and active multi-party collaboration, bolstered by member states' political commitment and good governance. While this work may not be swift or simple, it is indispensable to enhancing energy market linkages, promoting regional development, and ensuring stability. Achieving the numerous benefits of greater South-South energy integration relies on fostering a collective willingness to cooperate on regional trade agreements, adopting market-based energy prices across the region, and developing shared infrastructure, such as pipelines and power grids, to facilitate energy resource transportation and distribution among regional countries. In addition, harmonizing regulations and policies could create a more cohesive regional energy market, which is currently characterized by a patchwork of regulations and policies. Sharing technology and expertise among countries in the region represents another crucial element of promoting energy integration. Furthermore, ensuring a fair distribution of benefits could alleviate potential disparities that energy integration may generate among.

RELATED CONTENT

  • Authors
    Konrad-Adenauer-Stiftung in partnerships with the Policy Center for the New South and EastWest Institute
    July 3, 2020
    The Middle East and North Africa (MENA) have enormous economic potential with remarkable natural resources and industrial production capacities. While considerable progress for economic reforms has been reached already, a deeper regional integration and stronger cooperation can provide the needed impetus for facilitated development and upgraded national as well as regional economic structures in the wider region. Special Economic Zones (SEZs) present significant untapped potential, ...
  • Authors
    Alioune Sall
    Moubarack Lo
    July 2, 2020
    La transformation de la Communauté Economique des Etats de l’Afrique de l’Ouest (CEDEAO) en « confédération d’Etats » est parfois évoquée, y compris au niveau des Chefs d’Etat de la Communauté, comme une prochaine étape naturelle du processus d’approfondissement de l’intégration en Afrique de l’Ouest. La présente étude a pour objet d’en explorer la faisabilité et la pertinence, en se fondant sur l’expérience vécue dans d’autres continents. Une Confédération d’Etats peut être défini ...
  • Authors
    June 30, 2020
    Prior to the colonial era, money issuance in West Africa depended on slave trade. With the advent of the colonialrule, silver coins were imported then progressively imposed as a tool of coercion. The post-colonial trajectory wasdifferent for former British and French colonies. While the former regained their monetary sovereignty, the lattercontinued under a monetary union under the auspices of France. The proposal of the Eco as a single currency forECOWAS is therefore a whole new st ...
  • Authors
    April 30, 2020
    La Communauté économique des Etats de l’Afrique de l’Ouest (CEDEAO) est souvent présentée comme étant le système d’intégration régionale le plus dynamique du continent africain. Les Conférences des chefs d’Etat et de Gouvernement y sont régulières, les citoyens de la Communauté disposent d’un passeport commun et les discussions sur une monnaie unique sont à l’ordre du jour. Néanmoins, le modèle de la CEDEAO souffre de deux paradoxes majeurs. Les paradoxes africains Le premier pa ...
  • Authors
    March 17, 2020
    The United Nations Economic Commission for Latin America and the Caribbean (UN-ECLAC) defines regional integration as a “multidimensional process which may take the form of coordination, cooperation, convergence and deep integration initiatives and whose scope extends not only to economic and trade issues, but to political, social, cultural and environmental ones as well.” As an organizing principle, the concept of regional integration has been around for some time in various config ...
  • Authors
    Seleman Yusuph Kitenge
    February 12, 2020
    The internet of Things as a disruptive technology of the day and trend brings in a huge sense of connectivity and interaction not only between objects or devices, but also the workforce within institutions to amplify efficiency and productivity. This paper provides insights and perspectives of how institutions can bridge the digital divide with upskilling strategies which unlock an expert IoT workforce. Particularly, it focuses on AUDA – NEPAD scope of work areas such as Economic In ...
  • Authors
    Pierre Jacquemot
    December 26, 2019
    Depuis 2000, selon une approche et un calendrier qui ont été maintes fois modifiés, les 15 membres de la Communauté Économique des États de l’Afrique de l’Ouest (CEDEAO) ont exprimé leur volonté d’accélérer le processus d’intégration monétaire dans la région. Le récent débat autour de la Zone franc et sa réforme, désormais décidée avec la France, mais également l’enthousiasme manifesté autour de la création de la Zone de libre-échange continentale (ZLEAf) formellement créée le 30 ma ...
  • November 19, 2019
    Pour le n•165 - automne 2019, Politique Internationale a interviewé Karim El Aynaoui, président du Policy Center for the New South, au sujet de la zone de libre échange continental, pour le dossier spécial « développement: les voies africaines ». Il y répond notamment aux questions suivantes : en quels termes faut-il repenser le développement  de l’Afrique ? Comment l’approche marocaine se définit-elle ? la façade atlantique de l’Afrique et l’importance de ses échanges avec l’Améri ...
  • November 5, 2019
    In this brief, we review the evidence on Morocco’s export concentration, discuss its causes, and then draw some policy implications. The main message is that Morocco needs to raise its game in some less familiar markets and move outside its comfort zone. This implies not only investments by private firms, greater efforts on export promotion by the government and professional associations, but also deeper changes within Morocco, including in its educational system. Over the past two ...
  • Authors
    Under the Supervision of
    October 2, 2019
    Africa is an economic region which holds great potential despite the risks associated with its development. Indeed, many experts agree that Africa is emerging as the new frontier for global growth. Boosted by its abundant natural resources, a young and vibrant population, strong urbanization, more stable macroeconomic conditions, more stringent economic policies, a constantly improving business climate and improving governance, Africa is on track for a structural transformation that ...