Publications /
Opinion

Back
Apocalypse Now
Authors
April 17, 2020

COVID-19 is neither the end of civilization nor the beginning of enlightenment. The virus is revealing something though: the ignorance of some people, who are convinced by ideas of conspiracies and plots—for example that the virus emerged from secret laboratories in Wuhan, China, or Washington D.C. Or that Bill Gates, the billionaire Microsoft and internet pioneer, planted the coronavirus to earn money by selling vaccines. Or that 5G wireless networks are responsible for the deadly pandemic, transporting the virus throughout the world.

Social media has enabled those previously on the fringes of popular opinion to find and communicate with likeminded others. As people try to understand the pandemic, noted the online magazine theconversation.com, and make sense of their lives in lockdown, so called ‘truth seekers’ are receiving unprecedented levels of attention on YouTube, Facebook and Twitter. “Although Facebook newsfeeds are littered with state-sanctioned public health advice, private groups are awash with bogus claims and misinformation that contradicts the official knowledge and political process,” a theconversation.com article noted.

A Growing Coronavirus Conspiracy

Coronavirus conspiracies were pushed daily by the commander in chief of the greatest military and economic power in the world, U.S. President Donald Trump. He did not believe in the danger of the virus, ignoring the urgent messages from his intelligence services, which, observing the oppressive Chinese quarantine methods in December, predicted the deadly virus could strike the United States. The President relied on his instincts, calming his nation with accusations that his political opponents were inventing horror scenarios to damage his credibility and chances of reelection, and that it was all a hoax. Close advisors such as Peter Navarro warned White House colleagues in January about a virus that could kill a million or two million Americans if no action was taken, but, supposedly, no alarm reached the President.

Conspiracy Theories ‘As Dangerous as the Virus Itself’

Fake news, distortions, inventions, lies, and conspiracy theories are shadowing serious public debate about the source of the virus and the vaccines needed to control its spread. The coronavirus has “given rise to a flood of conspiracy theories, disinformation and propaganda”, reported the New York Times“eroding public trust and undermining health officials in ways that could elongate and even outlast the pandemic.” Conspiracy claims, the New York Times said, seem “to give a senseless tragedy some degree of meaning, however dark.” Le Monde, a serious, reliable newspaper, informed its readers that shaving their beards off would not stop the virus. So-called experts suggested that if you hold your breath for ten seconds and you do not need to cough, you are free of the virus.

Daniel Jolley and Pia Lamberty, scholars of psychology, warned that the wave of coronavirus conspiracies “has the potential to be just as dangerous for societies as the outbreak itself.” They concluded: “Medical conspiracy theories have the power to increase distrust in medical authorities, which can impact people’s willingness to protect themselves.” One indication, visible among populist movements, is the reluctance to trust vaccines or antibiotics. The growing ecosystem of misinformation and public distrust has led the World Health Organization to warn of an “infodemic.”

The World’s Slide Into Fringe Populism

In Venezuela, dictator Nicolas Maduro suggested that the virus was an American bioweapon aimed at China. Brazil’s president, Jair Bolsonaro, insisted that the virus was less dangerous than experts claim and not worse than the ordinary flu. He went on Facebook to discredit scientific research. Facebook, Twitter, and Instagram removed Bolsonaro’s coronavirus-related posts because they spread disinformation and did “actual harm to people”. Italian populist Matteo Salvini, an opposition party leader, accused Beijing of developing a “lung supervirus” from rats and bats.

Medical conspiracies have been a growing problem for years, as has distrust of authority. Rumors and unbelievable claims are spread by everyday people whose critical faculties have been overwhelmed, psychologists say, by feelings of confusion and helplessness. The conspiracy theories, according to the New York Times all carry a common message: the only protection comes from possessing the secret truths that ‘they’—the establishment—don’t want you to hear. A searching for ‘coronavirus books’, reported Wired, can produce titles such as “Corona virus /COVID 19 controversy: conspiracy theories around the Demon virus from China”, the “Military Virus Apocalypse: Biological warfare, Bioweapons and China Coronavirus Pandemic”, implying that the virus is human made—the most captivating, popular conspiracy theory. Amazon has delisted some of the most dubious books, perhaps an indication that this is the end of the beginning and in a few months of continued lockdown we can return to whatever remains of normality.

RELATED CONTENT

  • Authors
    Mohammed Germouni
    April 10, 2020
    Dans cette période de catastrophe planétaire, le risque d'un nombre élevé de victimes en raison de la faiblesse des systèmes de santé de nombreux Etats africains, anglophones ou francophones, est plus qu’évident pour l’observateur averti. Les circonstances actuelles interdisent des commentaires évidemment superflus sur les infrastructures médicales, globalement défaillantes. Ces insuffisances sont connues et vécues au quotidien par les populations des diverses régions du continent, ...
  • Authors
    Joana Vieira Flores
    PhD
    April 10, 2020
    From the moment China reported a new mysterious disease to the WHO, in the last day of 2019, the scientific community started following the situation with increasing concern. However, in many places like the UK, where I live, and Portugal, where I am from, the collective memory of recent public health crises like SARS and Ebola added up to “much ado about nothing” – a massive media frenzy that promised a pandemic but did not deliver one. That is perhaps why it took so long to regist ...
  • Authors
    Yonas Adeto
    Thomas Gomart
    Paolo Magri
    Greg Mills
    Karin Von Hippel
    Guntram Wolff
    April 9, 2020
    في وقت توجه فيه كل دول العالم تركيزها نحو الشأن الداخلي لمواجهة وباء فيروس “كورونا”، أكد العديد من الباحثين المغاربة والأجانب في الشأن الاقتصادي والسياسي على ضروة التفكير بطرق يستطيع من خلالها فاعلون خارجيون تقديم المساعدة للدول الفقيرة، “ويجب أن تتم الاستجابات في إفريقيا من خلال تنفيذ أفضل الممارسات فيما يتعلق بالتعاون الدولي”. وفي ذات السياق دعا الخبراء، وجلهم مسؤولون عن مراكز دراسات أوربية وإفريقية ذات صيت عالمي، من بينهم الخبير الاقتصادي المغربي كريم العيناوي، مدير مركز السياسا ...
  • Authors
    Yonas Adeto
    Thomas Gomart
    Paolo Magri
    Greg Mills
    Karin Von Hippel
    Guntram Wolff
    April 9, 2020
    Covid-19 should change global politics. The speed and scale of its transmission, and the severity of its impact is not, we know now, to our cost. As the virus rapidly tracks people vectors worldwide, the control of its impact is inextricably linked to the availability of resources and depth of governance. For these reasons, global leaders should focus on its impact among the most vulnerable, and in particular in Africa. Just three months ago, on 31 December 2019, Chinese authoritie ...
  • Authors
    Hajar El Alaoui
    April 9, 2020
    L’évolution rapide de la pandémie du Covid-19, touchant actuellement 212 Etats et territoires— selon l’Organisation mondiale de la Santé « les territoires, les zones, les dépendances à l'étranger et d'autres juridictions de statut similaire » — a atteint 1 511 104 cas de contamination confirmés dont 328 661 guérisons et 88 338 décès à la date du 8 avril 2020 à minuit. Les principaux foyers du virus étant alors les Etats-Unis, l’Espagne, l’Italie, suivis de la France, de l’Allemagne, ...
  • Authors
    Yonas Adeto
    Thomas Gomart
    Paolo Magri
    Greg Mills
    Karin Von Hippel
    Guntram Wolff
    April 9, 2020
    Il coronavirus promette di cambiare la politica globale. La velocità e la portata del contagio, così come la gravità del suo impatto, non sono fake news, come abbiamo già imparato a nostre spese. Il virus si diffonde rapidamente nel mondo, passando da persona a persona, e il contenimento delle sue conseguenze è indissolubilmente legato alla disponibilità di risorse e al buon funzionamento dei meccanismi di governance. Per queste ragioni, i leader globali dovrebbero porre molta atten ...
  • Authors
    Yonas Adeto
    Thomas Gomart
    Paolo Magri
    Greg Mills
    Karin Von Hippel
    Guntram Wolff
    April 9, 2020
    Alors que le coronavirus se propage à travers le monde, la capacité d’atténuer son impact est liée aux ressources disponibles et à l’efficacité des autorités publiques. Voilà pourquoi il nous paraît primordial que les dirigeants internationaux se concentrent sur les conséquences de la pandémie sur les plus vulnérables, en particulier en Afrique. Il y a trois mois, le 31 décembre, les autorités chinoises informaient le bureau de Pékin de l’Organisation mondiale de la santé (OMS) d’u ...
  • Authors
    Salma Daoudi
    April 8, 2020
    The coronavirus pandemic represents a turning point in security studies, shedding light on the importance of the health of populations for sustaining the political, economic, and social health of the nation-state. Playing a role akin to the 9/11 events in propelling terrorism at the forefront of the global security agenda, COVID-19 reshuffles national security priorities. As such, the securitization of health has allowed the implementation of drastic exceptional measures aimed at co ...
  • Authors
    April 7, 2020
    Le monde : ‘’Une société de crise’’ La multiplication de catastrophes naturelles et la montée de leur probabilité d’occurrence, la répétition des crises de tous genres (économiques, politiques, sociales et sécuritaires) et l’interdépendance accrue, du fait de la mondialisation, ont mis au premier plan le facteur de la résilience[1]. En effet, il ne s’agit plus d’évaluer le risque ou de l’anticiper, tellement sa probabilité d’occurrence s’est accrue, mais surtout de limiter les dégâ ...
  • Authors
    Mouhamadou Moustapha Ly
    April 7, 2020
    Le Covidonomics est la branche de l’analyse économique qui s’intéresse aux mécanismes par lesquels la pandémie affecte les économies du monde ainsi que les réponses de politiques économiques qui puissent répondre aux défis inhérents à la propagation du Covid-19. */ La présente contribution propose des réponses de politiques économiques et sanitaires qui soient contextualisées suivant trois périodes. La crise sanitaire Covid-19, au même titre que l’angoissante question du changemen ...