Publications /
Opinion

Back
To solve extreme poverty, give people money
Authors
March 4, 2024

This blog was originally published on huawei.com

 

What impact do you think ICT and connectivity can have in fighting global poverty?

At the World Bank we had a very enthusiastic and optimistic view on the potential impact of technology and ICT. Brazil had a cash transfer program for poorer families where households received money directly from the government, regardless of whether they had bank accounts. The money was not distributed by hand but done electronically: the government had built a registry of 25 million Brazilians considered to be below the poverty threshold. The money was transferred to the women of the household. It had a huge impact because it was straightforward and empowered the families, particularly the women, giving them money for basic needs. 

One of the advantages of this kind of technological registry was that we could know the poor by name. We could potentially collect information on their different needs, in terms of infrastructure, education, health care and so on, that could give the government a potential guide for specific policy interventions in particular neighborhoods. Multilateral institutions do not govern, they support; they give policy advice and finance programs. But in addition to providing funds, a major function of the World Bank is to play a hummingbird role. Hummingbirds pollinate flowers, and these multilateral institutions can also pollinate with knowledge. 

With the Brazilian experience, the World Bank was keen to learn and participate – helping Brazil to develop a system for checking whether the money was really reaching those who needed and deserved it. And it was amazing: the rate of good targeting was close to 95%, with just a 5% margin of error. The Bank was ready to disseminate the experience with other interested countries, although Asians are not fond of this kind of direct cash transfer, as it’s seen to potentially undermine the will of poor people to get out of poverty. But overall we were proud to play this hummingbird role, to be the bridge in terms of knowledge dissemination and knowledge pollination.

 

And was it connectivity that provided the ability to share the knowledge?

We knew the role ICT could play in battling global poverty, because it provides tools and solutions that empower individuals and communities. Access to information and education is facilitated by ICT, which makes it potentially easier to break the cycle of poverty. But you need certain conditions in place – the infrastructure and affordable access to it for the adoption of ICT tools – so governments and organizations need to invest in building this infrastructure. 

We did a survey in 2010 which found that, in the poorest 20% of households, seven out of ten had a mobile phone. They were more likely to have access to mobile phones than to toilets or to clean water. It’s incredible. But that allowed financial inclusion, as shown by the experience of countries like Kenya, with its M-Pesa digital payment system. Even with the old-style, more primitive cellphones, they were able to develop a network that reduced the cost of a remittance. 

I also remember meeting the former UN Secretary-General, Kofi Annan, who he talked about a project to install cell phone towers around Lake Victoria. The number of casualties because of storms taking fishermen by surprise was significant. And this network would provide weather warnings to be shared with inhabitants surrounding the lake through cellphones using visual mechanisms – so even illiterate people could be warned. I remember how enthusiastic we all became with this great example of how ICT can improve the conditions of poor people. 

 

It comes back to your point about access to information, about knowledge and being able to access these services.

Exactly. ICT can also help farmers, informing them about weather patterns, market price, where to locate their products, and also best practices in farming. I saw it in Brazil, where an agricultural engineer explained to me how he cherry-picked 18 different types of seeds appropriate to the needs of his soil. He was able to maximize his activity using equipment and weather forecasting to decide when to seed, when to collect and so on. 

There’s so much potential. But for ICT to become concrete and effective, you have to have the corresponding policies in place – that access to reliable and affordable internet infrastructure. And also promotion of digital literacy, to help those Lake Victoria inhabitants do even better, for instance. You have to have the regulatory framework, to encourage innovation, and at the same time, protect the interests of users. 

ICT with AI is a double-edged sword. It has a tremendous potential to increase productivity and to facilitate learning, but it has the potential to exclude too, with questions about security and misinformation. So it's a double-edged sword. It all depends on the presence of a regulatory framework. You have to have an environment where public-private partnerships can flourish, so as to accelerate the deployment of ICT solutions and reach the underserved. So there is potential but there is also risk.

 

Is that risk especially acute for poorer areas? 

Education is the base. We should not underestimate the potential of learning and development among poor people: once they have the basics, they can go up the ladder. And there are improvements in governance that can come with ICT. In one case, parents of schoolchildren had an app to give information to the central government about the attendance (or not) of teachers at school. With this mechanism of bottom-up monitoring, the absence of teachers dropped dramatically. This improvement was made possible by ICT.

 

The goal of SDG1 is to eradicate extreme poverty worldwide, and half of all poverty worldwide by 2030. Is it going to be achieved – and if not, why not?

We have made undeniable progress towards those goals, owing to a combination of world economic growth and policies directed at exactly that goal. More recently, however, it looks like we have stagnated, particularly in Africa. But let’s go back: do you know why the Brazilian cash transfers that I spoke about earlier went to the women?

 

Because the women will spend it more responsibly?

A survey done in the 1990s in Brazil, and replicated in other parts of the world, shows that in households where women have a strong say over how resources are used, the weight and height of babies are better than those where the male is in charge. When I gave classes in very chauvinistic or very racist places I would say: “Well, gender colleagues, the women are just better, and that's the proof.”

 

So, when it comes to tackling extreme poverty, basically go through women. Looking after them should be your starting point?

That’s exactly right. They prioritize the use of resources, and this could have long-term implications. Children who are better fed, and with better school and health attendance – and the money is conditional on that – will be higher human capital when they become adults.

RELATED CONTENT

  • From

    23
    4:30 pm February 2022
    Les hostilités commerciales entre la Chine et les États-Unis, qui se sont intensifiées sous la présidence de D. Trump et qui se sont poursuivies sous l'administration américaine actuelle, marquent un tournant dans la libéralisation de l'économie mondiale depuis la fin de la Seconde Guerre mondiale. Le système commercial mondial est en ruine en raison de cette guerre commerciale, ainsi que du démantèlement du processus de règlement des différends de l'Organisation mondiale du commerce et des violations fréquentes des règles par ses membres. Cependant le système commercial d'après-guerre ne touche pas à sa fin ; il évolue plutôt vers un ensemble d'interactions commerciales plus compliquées, politiques et controversées. La nouvelle structure sera très probablement basée sur une O ...
  • From

    16
    5:30 pm February 2022
    Rida Lyammouri, Senior Fellow at Policy Center for the New South, will be speaking at the webinar “security and governence in africa: sahel and libya” organized by frica Study Group in partnership with The Middle East Institute. The security dynamics of the Maghreb and the Sahel are intertwined and the consequences of the Libyan conflict on the Sahel have been serious. Since its beginning in 2011, this conflict has triggered global concern about the economic, security, and geostrategic impacts on the Sahel. Current threats are posed by the illicit transfer, destabilizing accumulation, and misuse of arms, as well as the flow of armed groups and mercenaries. Despite considerable international efforts, especially by African countries, the Sahel is still experiencing one of the ...
  • From

    14
    2:00 pm February 2022
    Aomar Ibourk, Senior Fellow au Policy Center for the New South, interviendra lors d’une table ronde dans le cadre d’un webinaire de présentation du rapport « Paysage de l’emploi au Maroc » organisé par la Banque mondiale et le Haut-Commissariat au Plan. L’objectif du webinaire sera de présenter les résultats clés du rapport « Paysage de l’emploi au Maroc » par le Haut-Commissariat au Plan et par la Banque mondiale, suivi par une discussion sur les principaux faits saillants du rapport et la présentation des points de vue des différents panélistes sur le marché du travail marocain et les perspectives de l’emploi au Maroc. A l’issue de ces présentations, une table ronde de discussion autour du rapport sera animée. Cet évènement aura lieu le Lundi 14 Février 2022 à 14 :00 (GM ...
  • Authors
    Benjamin Augé
    While the Brent oil prices in London have been fluctuating between 20 and 35 dollars per barrel for several weeks, and while American oil prices in New York even reached negative values on 20 April, most African oil-producing countries have, at the end of 2019, passed their 2020 budgets on the basis of rather optimistic forecasts, sometimes betting on an increase in expenditure financed by borrowing (Nigeria). Some of these countries were expecting Brent prices to be rather high in ...
  • Authors
    L'environnement dans lequel fonctionnent les systèmes financiers des pays arabes du Sud de la Méditerranée (PASM)1 a changé ces deux dernières décennies. Ces systèmes pays ont connu de profondes mutations depuis le déclenchement de la crise financière internationale. Certes ils n’ont pas subi de conséquences directes de la crise, mais la dégradation de la croissance mondiale a eu des effets majeurs sur les économies de ces pays. Les tensions politiques de la région ont aussi forteme ...